An axe to Nominalism and Christmas Every Day
Rod Dreher in his seminal 'The Benediction Option' (2017) identifies the emergence of Nominalism in the later part of Medieval civilisation as the start of all our troubles with modernity. It is no easy thing to describe what Nominalism is but it appears to be the first of four intellectual movements which have brought us to a post-Christian Europe. As Matthew Arnold claimed in his 'Sea of Faith' poem we are witnessing the receding of shores of belief. Of course, the yarn we are sold is that the Church's demise is due to the superiority of the scientific worldview, the moral failings of the clergy and poor marketing. However, notwithstanding this criticism I want to suggest that Nominalism was from the start a big cause for the Christian worldview to collapse in the West. Basically, Nominalism views that stuff is stuff and the world is not a magical or supernaturally charged place. God is therefore one of many beings and it just happens that he is very bi...